England managed to secure a 2-0 victory over Andorra in their latest World Cup qualifying match at Villa Park, but the performance left much to be desired, prompting criticism from Sky Sports pundit Roy Keane. Despite dominating possession, the Three Lions struggled to break down Andorra's organized defense and create clear-cut chances.

A Struggled Victory
England's win came courtesy of an own goal in the first half and a second-half header from Declan Rice, but the match was far from convincing. The team managed just 11 shots from 83% possession, highlighting their inefficiency in front of goal. The victory, while maintaining their perfect record in Group K, was a far cry from the high standards set by manager Thomas Tuchel ahead of the match.

Keane's Criticism
Sky Sports pundit Roy Keane was particularly vocal in his critique of England's play. "They fell back into their old ways tonight, certainly in the second half," Keane said on ITV. "Sideways, backwards passes. They've got to cross it a bit more, don't complicate the game. And I still think they go backwards too many times."

Keane's comments echoed the frustration felt by many fans and analysts, who noted England's inability to maintain forward momentum and capitalize on their dominance in possession. The team's failure to create clear opportunities for captain Harry Kane, who was largely anonymous throughout the match, was a significant point of contention.

Tuchel's Mixed Reaction
Manager Thomas Tuchel, while pleased with certain aspects of the performance, acknowledged areas for improvement. "We missed the little moments to accelerate the game," Tuchel said in his post-match press conference. He specifically highlighted the performances of attackers Eberechi Eze, Noni Madueke, and Marcus Rashford, noting that they struggled to make decisive plays in the final third.

Tuchel praised the overall attitude and preparation of the team, stating, "I'm very positive about the group that was in camp now and how they presented themselves, how they behaved, how they trained and how we played today." However, he admitted that the team could have scored earlier, which would have given them more freedom in the second half.

Bright Spot: Elliot Anderson
One bright spot in the match was the debut performance of Elliot Anderson, who impressed as a deep-lying midfielder. Tuchel had previously identified this position as a concern for England, but Anderson's performance earned him praise from the manager.

"Tuchel had flagged this as a problem position for England before the game, hinting centre-back John Stones could be the best option, but he said Anderson 'passed the test' and could continue in the role going forwards, starting with Serbia away on Tuesday," the report noted.

Tuchel described Anderson as "a very, very good football player" who demonstrated strong physicality and mobility. "He's just a very mobile No 6, he loves to defend, he loves to put his body inside, he loves passing, he loves to break the lines, he's just very mobile in this game, it was a pleasure to see," Tuchel said.

Looking Ahead
With the victory, England maintains their perfect record in Group K, but the performance against Andorra raises questions about their readiness for tougher opponents. The team will face Serbia away on Tuesday, a match that will provide a clearer indication of their progress under Tuchel.

As England continues its World Cup qualifying campaign, the focus will be on addressing the issues highlighted by Keane and Tuchel, particularly in terms of forward play and decision-making in the final third. The team's ability to improve in these areas will be crucial as they prepare for the upcoming matches and the 2026 World Cup.